By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.
Accept
routeonerouteonerouteone
  • News
    • Show all
    • Awards & Events
    • Deliveries
    • Environment
    • Exhibitor News
    • Euro Bus Expo 2024
    • Features
    • Legal
    • Minibus and minicoach
    • Operators
    • Opinion
    • People
    • Suppliers
    • Vehicles
  • Vehicles
    • Find a Vehicle
    • ZEV Comparison Tool
    • Sell a Vehicle
    • Vehicle Seller Dashboard
  • Insights
  • Careers
  • Events
    • British Tourism & Travel Show
    • Euro Bus Expo
    • Innovation Challenge
    • Livery Competition
    • routeone Awards
  • Advertise
  • Contact
    • Share your news
    • Subscribe
    • Update Subscription Details
  • Latest Issue
  • SIGN UP
Search
© 2024 routeone News. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Politics: Chinese whispers making much noise in bus circles
Share
Font ResizerAa
routeonerouteone
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • News
    • Show all
    • Awards & Events
    • Deliveries
    • Environment
    • Exhibitor News
    • Euro Bus Expo 2024
    • Features
    • Legal
    • Minibus and minicoach
    • Operators
    • Opinion
    • People
    • Suppliers
    • Vehicles
  • Vehicles
    • Find a Vehicle
    • ZEV Comparison Tool
    • Sell a Vehicle
    • Vehicle Seller Dashboard
  • Insights
  • Careers
  • Events
    • British Tourism & Travel Show
    • Euro Bus Expo
    • Innovation Challenge
    • Livery Competition
    • routeone Awards
  • Advertise
  • Contact
    • Share your news
    • Subscribe
    • Update Subscription Details
  • Latest Issue
  • SIGN UP
Follow US
© 2024 routeone News | Powered by Diversified Business Communications UK Ltd
- Advertisement -
-
routeone > Opinion > Politics: Chinese whispers making much noise in bus circles
Opinion

Politics: Chinese whispers making much noise in bus circles

Complaints linger that foreign manufacturers benefit from government policies, but the issue is a complex one, says our Westminster correspondent

Westminster Watcher
Westminster Watcher
Published: October 21, 2024
Share
Alexander Dennis’s ire over foreign imports has raised Parliamentary questions
Alexander Dennis’s ire over foreign imports has raised Parliamentary questions
SHARE

News that Alexander Dennis is to make some 160 redundancies, citing the impact of competition from overseas bus manufacturers which, it claims, are beneficiaries of state aid, will inevitably spark a fresh round of debate about the merits or otherwise of buying new zero-emission buses from Chinese manufacturers.

Contents
An ongoing issueUK government aidFranchising changesMs Haigh’s bold claim

Already, Paul Sweeney, the Labour MSP for the Glasgow region, has tabled a question in the Scottish parliament on the issue and has called on the Scottish Government to revise its social value conditions on public funds being used to subsidise foreign bus manufacturers.

The Government’s answer highlighted, of course, that bus operators are free to choose the manufacturers from which they want to buy buses and reminded us that Scottish ministers are required to comply with the terms of the Subsidy Control Act, which prohibits the favouring of domestic over non-domestic manufacturers.

UK manufacturers also benefit from government grants and loan guarantees

The answer to Mr Sweeney’s question also stated that Alexander Dennis has been in receipt of more than £23 million in research and development grant funding since 2020 to support the company’s ability to secure new orders for ultra-low and zero-emission buses. And nobody seemed to mind, not least the business itself, when Alexander Dennis had a joint venture with BYD, thereby benefiting from the Chinese manufacturer’s battery and chassis technology to help it win many orders, especially in London.

An ongoing issue

I’m quite sure this issue isn’t going to go away. From time to time, MPs in Westminster and MSPs in Holyrood table questions and secure parliamentary debates to bemoan the purchase of new buses from Chinese manufacturers, complaining that they benefit from Chinese government aid, thus placing UK manufacturers at a disadvantage, while also citing concerns over the Chinese government’s human-rights record.

I’m not going to enter into a debate about the rights or wrongs of operators buying buses from Chinese manufacturers. It’s not a straightforward issue. I want to see UK companies succeed, of course. But I also want to see a competitive market and I am not sure that the wider geopolitical issues around trade with China is one for bus operators to be influenced by.

UK government aid

However, when I hear UK bus manufacturers complaining about unfair competition, with their Chinese rivals benefiting from state aid, I remind myself that UK manufacturers also benefit from government grants and loan guarantees now and again.

Now, if the Chinese manufacturers do benefit from support from their government, it may well be that this is on a scale way in excess of that which UK manufacturers receive from our Treasury. I just don’t know the answer to that.

500th BYD ADL electric bus
‘Nobody seemed to mind, not least the business itself, when Alexander Dennis had a joint venture with BYD, thereby benefiting from the Chinese manufacturer’s battery and chassis technology to help it win many orders’

But the support that UK manufacturers receive is not insubstantial — something that needs to be borne in mind. As I say, now that Alexander Dennis has announced its redundancy plans, I’m sure we can expect renewed debate on the issue both in Holyrood and Westminster.

Franchising changes

Meanwhile, the Department for Transport (DfT) has laid an Order, or Statutory Instrument, before parliament which, when passed, will remove the requirement for non-mayoral authorities to secure the approval of DfT to make a bus franchise scheme. Nevertheless, these authorities would still need the Department’s approval to make the initial assessment of a franchise scheme, something that can only be removed by primary legislation rather than a simple Statutory Instrument.

Quite why ministers felt the need to make a separate Statutory Instrument to remove the requirement to gain approval to set up a franchise scheme rather than wrap everything up together in the Buses Bill, which is coming soon, I’m far from clear. After all, no non-mayoral authority is now suddenly going to rush ahead to make a franchise scheme anyway. So, what’s the point? I guess Transport Secretary Louise Haigh just wanted to do a bit of sabre-rattling and show that she was getting on with things.

Ms Haigh’s bold claim

At least she is trying to be good to her word that, as she said in her speech to the Labour Party Conference, she will “move fast and fix things”.

This is understandable political rhetoric from a new government, but it’s dangerous rhetoric too because, if the travelling public don’t see much difference in the quality and reliability of their public transport services in, say, a year’s time, this claim of moving fast and fixing things will come back to bite her.

Transport Secretary Louise Haigh has shown ambition to get things done with new legislation concerning franchising

If, in a year’s time, no new bus franchise scheme has been made, and if the performance of those rail franchises which are under public sector control hasn’t markedly improved, I wonder what the travelling public, let alone the electorate, will make of Ms Haigh’s bold claim that she will “move fast and fix things”.

For example, Northern Rail, which was brought back under state control in March 2020 has a cancellation rate four times higher than in 2014 when it was under private ownership. Network Rail, a nationalised body under the direct control of DfT, is responsible for some 70% of all delays and cancellations on the railways.

Ministers need to be careful about making bold claims when many of the factors that affect bus and train performance aren’t under their control

My point is that, tempting as it may be, especially for a new government that’s been in opposition for so long, ministers need to be careful about making bold claims when many of the factors that affect bus and train performance aren’t under their control.

The good news for Ms Haigh, for now at least, is that, while the Conservative party is going through its protracted leadership contest, there is no real scrutiny of the government’s performance — at least in political and parliamentary terms. All the scrutiny today is from the media, which seems to be falling out of love with Labour remarkably quickly.

Once the Conservatives have their new leader in early November and a consequential reshuffle of the shadow cabinet and shadow ministerial team has taken place, we can expect — or should expect — renewed political scrutiny of Labour’s policies and performance in government. Labour is discovering, I suspect, that being in government is a whole lot more difficult than being in opposition.

Share This Article
Facebook LinkedIn Threads Email Copy Link
Previous Article Bus-focused planning will create greener communities Planning reform efforts must put bus services first
Next Article October: The time of year for a coach industry health check
- Advertisement -

Latest News

Temsa HD12 and HD13 delivered to Cresta Coaches under Asset Alliance rental deal
Temsa pair join Cresta Coaches on Asset Alliance rental agreement
Deliveries
Go-Ahead London – Managing Director
Careers Jobs
andy burnham tfgm £15.6 billion (1) The funding announced by Chancellor Rachel Reeves today (4 June) has been allocated to several combined mayoral authorities to use on rail, tram, road and bus infrastructure. Transport for Greater Manchester revealed today that part of the £2.5 billion it will receive will go towards making the Bee Network fully battery-electric by 2030. An as-yet undecided portion of that will support a planned investment in 1,000 new zero-emission buses over that period, the mayoral authority said. That is part of plans to build the UK's "first fully integrated, zero-emission public transport system", with trams and trains also set to benefit. Liverpool City Region's already announced BRT system is among the projects to which its £1.6 billion will be allocated. Under those plans - due for realisation by 2028 - a high-speed network will be served by articulated buses which are modelled on the 'Glider' in Belfast. It is due to link Liverpool city centre with John Lennon Airport, and Liverpool FC and Everton FC's respective stadia along three routes. Although the model of bus has not been confirmed, a Van Hool Exqui.City on loan from Belfast was last year used as a demonstrator. That 18m vehicle can accommodate around 30% more passengers than a typical bus and has three sets of double doors. The funding will also go towards buses elsewhere in the city as the region heads towards franchising services by 2027. Liverpool Mayor Steve Rotheram with a 'Glider' which was on loan from Belfast last year - an example of the sort of bus which could serve the new BRT Bus services in the East Midlands region will be boosted by the funding, thanks to the £2 billion handed to it today by the government. Some of that allocation will be used for a rapid transit network on the Trent Arc between Nottingham and Derby. Between the two cities, the Freeport, Infinity Park Investment Zone and Ratcliffe-on-Soar will also benefit from the improved bus services. South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority's newly announced commitment towards bus franchising has been boosted by £350 million in funding as part of that region's allocation. The funding for West Yorkshire will help build new bus stations in Bradford and Wakefield. Likewise, the Tees Valley Mayoral Authority will put its sum towards a new £15 million bus station in Middlesbrough. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander says: "Today marks a watershed moment on our journey to improving transport across the North and Midlands – opening up access to jobs, growing the economy and driving up quality of life as we deliver our Plan for Change. "For too long, people in the North and Midlands have been locked out of the investment they deserve. With £15.6bn of government investment, we’re giving local leaders the means to drive cities, towns and communities forward, investing in Britain’s renewal so you and your family are better off."
TfGM’s all-electric bus plan boosted by new £15.6 billion package
News
Local Transport Minister opens First Bus electric depot in Hengrove
Local Transport Minister opens First Bus electric depot in Hengrove
Bus
- Advertisement -
-

routeone magazine is the indispensable resource for professional UK coach, bus and minibus operators. The home of vehicle sales and the latest bus and coach job vacancies, routeone connects professional PCV operators with complete and unrivalled news coverage.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • GDPR Policy
  • Sustainability
  • Advertise
  • Latest Issue
  • Share Your News
routeonerouteone
Follow US
© 2024 routeone News | Powered by Diversified Business Communications UK Ltd