By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.
Accept
routeonerouteonerouteone
  • News
    • Show all
    • Awards & Events
    • Deliveries
    • Environment
    • Exhibitor News
    • Euro Bus Expo 2024
    • Features
    • Legal
    • Minibus and minicoach
    • Operators
    • Opinion
    • People
    • Suppliers
    • Vehicles
  • Vehicles
    • Find a Vehicle
    • ZEV Comparison Tool
    • Sell a Vehicle
    • Vehicle Seller Dashboard
  • Insights
  • Careers
  • Events
    • British Tourism & Travel Show
    • Euro Bus Expo
    • Innovation Challenge
    • Livery Competition
    • routeone Awards
  • Advertise
  • Contact
    • Share your news
    • Subscribe
    • Update Subscription Details
  • Latest Issue
  • SIGN UP
Search
© 2024 routeone News. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: TC refuses Carmel Coaches’ new licence application
Share
Font ResizerAa
routeonerouteone
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • News
    • Show all
    • Awards & Events
    • Deliveries
    • Environment
    • Exhibitor News
    • Euro Bus Expo 2024
    • Features
    • Legal
    • Minibus and minicoach
    • Operators
    • Opinion
    • People
    • Suppliers
    • Vehicles
  • Vehicles
    • Find a Vehicle
    • ZEV Comparison Tool
    • Sell a Vehicle
    • Vehicle Seller Dashboard
  • Insights
  • Careers
  • Events
    • British Tourism & Travel Show
    • Euro Bus Expo
    • Innovation Challenge
    • Livery Competition
    • routeone Awards
  • Advertise
  • Contact
    • Share your news
    • Subscribe
    • Update Subscription Details
  • Latest Issue
  • SIGN UP
Follow US
© 2024 routeone News | Powered by Diversified Business Communications UK Ltd
- Advertisement -
-
routeone > Legal > TC refuses Carmel Coaches’ new licence application
LegalOperators

TC refuses Carmel Coaches’ new licence application

Mike Jewell
Mike Jewell
Published: December 14, 2021
Share
Carmel has had licence revoked several times for ‘substantial maintenance shortcomings’
SHARE

Operator dubbed ‘a danger to the PSV industry’ has new licence application refused at Bristol Public Inquiry 

An application for a new 10-vehicle international licence by Okehampton-based Carmel Coaches, which has Anthony Hazell as one of its Directors and Transport Manager (TM), has been refused by Traffic Commissioner (TC) Nick Denton following a Bristol Public Inquiry (PI). 

Carmel Coaches was granted an international licence for 40 vehicles in May 2011. The Directors were Anthony Hazell, Michael Hazell, Anthony’s son, and Anthony’s daughter Carolyn Alderton. 

The licence was subsequently revoked owing to severe maintenance shortcomings. Anthony Hazell was disqualified for 18 months from acting as a Director and TM. An appeal against those decisions was dismissed by the Upper Tribunal [routeone/Court Report/12 November 2014]. 

Carmel Coaches was granted an international licence for 15 vehicles in December 2016 after the TC found that Anthony Hazell’s good repute was restored [routeone/Court Report/25 January 2017]. That licence was subsequently revoked for substantial maintenance shortcomings. 

TC Kevin Rooney found that Anthony Hazell had lost his good repute as a TM and disqualified him from acting as such until he retook and passed the TM CPC examination [routeone/Court Report/January 2021]. 

A pre-hearing statement stated that Ms Alderton was a fellow Director but would have limited involvement in the business as she had her own operation based in Bristol. The intention was to undertake mainly private hire work, as council contracts for school travel were unlikely to be awarded given the company’s previous history. 

Anthony Hazell intended to drive and employ an additional driver, together with an office manager and a self-employed fitter. The initial plan had been to share safety inspections between BVS and the fitter Steven Waters. 

Anthony Hazell acknowledged that there had been strong criticism of Mr Waters’ effectiveness. He was now proposing to use Scania of Exeter to undertake all pre-MoT inspections and six-weekly safety inspections. Anthony Hazell had undertaken a two-day training course in February 2021 before taking and passing the TM CPC exam. He had also undertaken a day’s tachograph training in May 2021. 

Anthony Hazell said that he did not want to overstretch himself, so he had reduced his application from 10 to five vehicles, which he could comfortably manage. 

BVS had been unable to accommodate his vehicles, so he had arranged with Scania to do all the periodic safety inspections. Mr Waters was coming up to retirement but for the moment would be retained as a fitter, carrying out minor repairs. 

Scania or Mr Waters would prepare vehicles for MoT. Roller brake tests would be carried out every 12 weeks or at every six-week inspection if the TC preferred. He would investigate the causes of any MoT failures and address them. His vehicles’ MoT pass rate had not been bad given their age. He would undertake regular CPC refresher courses from now on. 

The revocation of the company’s licence in 2020 had had a drastic and humiliating effect on him, particularly regarding his standing in the local community. He had taken on board the TC’s criticism and was determined to get it right this time. 

In reply to the TC, Anthony Hazell said that he was prepared to undertake that Mr Waters would not prepare vehicles for MoT. He could live with a reduced authority of three vehicles, the number in possession, if that was what it took to be granted a licence.  

He was prepared to undertake further training on how to interpret roller brake test print-outs – an issue on which TC Rooney had severely criticised him. He was prepared to rewrite the company mobile phone policy to address the issue of hands-free use, which had been a contributory factor to a fatal crash involving one of the firm’s vehicles in 2014. 

Refusing the application, the TC said that there was much on the positive side. However, while admiring Anthony Hazell in some respects, he could not ignore his record or overlook some worrying current elements. 

No fewer than three different TCs and the Upper Tribunal had been severely critical of Anthony Hazell and his ability to run a compliant operation over the past seven years. TC Sarah Bell expressed “grave doubts as to Anthony Hazell’s judgement and integrity. He was not capable or competent to operate the necessary systems to ensure vehicles remain roadworthy when in service and in a lawful manner”. 

In dismissing the appeal, the Upper Tribunal said that “on any view, this is a very bad case”, referring to the “serious and sustained maintenance failings” involved. In October 2019, TC Nick Jones found that “Anthony Hazell is a danger to the PSV industry as he is so grossly incompetent” [routeone/Court Report/2 October 2019]. 

TC Kevin Rooney commented that Anthony Hazell “appears so certain in his own flawed thinking that he has simply lost the ability to listen and therefore to learn”. His “approach is old-school. There might be nothing wrong with that normally, but with Anthony Hazell, the degree is such that it makes him dangerous”.   

He had rarely read such damning remarks by TCs about an individual, let alone three sets of such remarks relating to the same person. At the hearing, Anthony Hazell stated that he had indeed taken these lessons to heart and was a changed man. However, there were some elements in the application and his manner at the PI, which caused him to doubt whether that was true. 

The fact that the licence application was originally for 10 vehicles and had fitter Steven Waters on a par with Scania did not convince the TC that Anthony Hazell had in mind a radically streamlined and different operation from the outset. 

He had shown himself prepared to make concessions when asked to do so, but it did not seem to have occurred to him to include them in his original plans. 

Anthony Hazell also appeared to forget one of the changes offered. In his prior written submission, he stated that only Scania would prepare vehicles for MoT, whereas at the hearing, he stated that both Mr Waters and Scania would do that. The issue was not a trivial one, as TC Rooney was so critical of the fact that Mr Waters appeared incapable of preparing and keeping vehicles in a condition where they would consistently pass their MoT. 

He was unable to conclude that Anthony Hazell had re-established his good repute as a TM or that he could trust him or the company to comply with requirements relating to roadworthiness of vehicles. 

Share This Article
Facebook LinkedIn Threads Email Copy Link
Previous Article Time to hold ‘the government’s feet to the fire’
Next Article Go North East takes on 11 engineering and bodybuilder apprentices
- Advertisement -

Latest News

Go-Ahead London – Managing Director
Careers Jobs
andy burnham tfgm £15.6 billion (1) The funding announced by Chancellor Rachel Reeves today (4 June) has been allocated to several combined mayoral authorities to use on rail, tram, road and bus infrastructure. Transport for Greater Manchester revealed today that part of the £2.5 billion it will receive will go towards making the Bee Network fully battery-electric by 2030. An as-yet undecided portion of that will support a planned investment in 1,000 new zero-emission buses over that period, the mayoral authority said. That is part of plans to build the UK's "first fully integrated, zero-emission public transport system", with trams and trains also set to benefit. Liverpool City Region's already announced BRT system is among the projects to which its £1.6 billion will be allocated. Under those plans - due for realisation by 2028 - a high-speed network will be served by articulated buses which are modelled on the 'Glider' in Belfast. It is due to link Liverpool city centre with John Lennon Airport, and Liverpool FC and Everton FC's respective stadia along three routes. Although the model of bus has not been confirmed, a Van Hool Exqui.City on loan from Belfast was last year used as a demonstrator. That 18m vehicle can accommodate around 30% more passengers than a typical bus and has three sets of double doors. The funding will also go towards buses elsewhere in the city as the region heads towards franchising services by 2027. Liverpool Mayor Steve Rotheram with a 'Glider' which was on loan from Belfast last year - an example of the sort of bus which could serve the new BRT Bus services in the East Midlands region will be boosted by the funding, thanks to the £2 billion handed to it today by the government. Some of that allocation will be used for a rapid transit network on the Trent Arc between Nottingham and Derby. Between the two cities, the Freeport, Infinity Park Investment Zone and Ratcliffe-on-Soar will also benefit from the improved bus services. South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority's newly announced commitment towards bus franchising has been boosted by £350 million in funding as part of that region's allocation. The funding for West Yorkshire will help build new bus stations in Bradford and Wakefield. Likewise, the Tees Valley Mayoral Authority will put its sum towards a new £15 million bus station in Middlesbrough. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander says: "Today marks a watershed moment on our journey to improving transport across the North and Midlands – opening up access to jobs, growing the economy and driving up quality of life as we deliver our Plan for Change. "For too long, people in the North and Midlands have been locked out of the investment they deserve. With £15.6bn of government investment, we’re giving local leaders the means to drive cities, towns and communities forward, investing in Britain’s renewal so you and your family are better off."
TfGM’s all-electric bus plan boosted by new £15.6 billion package
News
Local Transport Minister opens First Bus electric depot in Hengrove
Local Transport Minister opens First Bus electric depot in Hengrove
Bus
Contract pricing conundrum for coach and bus
Contract pricing conundrum: Unlikely to get easier any time soon
Editor's Comment
- Advertisement -
-

routeone magazine is the indispensable resource for professional UK coach, bus and minibus operators. The home of vehicle sales and the latest bus and coach job vacancies, routeone connects professional PCV operators with complete and unrivalled news coverage.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • GDPR Policy
  • Sustainability
  • Advertise
  • Latest Issue
  • Share Your News
routeonerouteone
Follow US
© 2024 routeone News | Powered by Diversified Business Communications UK Ltd